We Love Cats Because They Don’t Love Us Back

ESSAYS

Anonymous

5/9/20253 min read

A Feline Love Letter from Your Favorite Emotional Masochist

There’s a very specific kind of person who becomes a cat person, and it’s not the type you think. It’s not just lonely introverts in cardigans (though, yes, sometimes we are), nor is it just people who hate dogs (although, frankly, we’re tired of being judged by golden retrievers who never blink). No—cat lovers are connoisseurs of rejection.

We like our love with a side of emotional humiliation. We enjoy earning affection that, let’s be honest, isn’t coming.

Dogs? Dogs are toddlers with Williams syndrome: too friendly, too attached, and always ready to throw a birthday party just because you entered the room. They see you, and they’re like, “I have never known greater joy than your existence. I would die for you. I would kill for you. Let me sniff your eyeballs.”

Cats?

Cats are the emotionally unavailable art school roommate who keeps a knife collection and eats edamame for dinner. They blink at you slowly like you're a mildly interesting wall stain.

And we. eat. it. up.

The Sadistic Joy of Loving a Creature That Doesn’t Care if You Die

There’s something exhilarating—almost sadistic—about trying to earn the affection of a small, fluffy despot who will never, ever love you as much as you love them.

I once spent 45 minutes lying perfectly still on the floor because my cat, decided to sit on my stomach. The moment I twitched a muscle, he left like I’d violated a centuries-old treaty. I whispered, “I’m sorry,” and then gave him a piece of chicken.

This is normal.

What’s abnormal is our collective delusion that this is some kind of relationship.

The Cat Love Equation

Love = (1 second of headbutt) + (4 hours of cold shoulder) x (occasional stabbing of your thigh mid-snuggle)

You may find a cat curled in your lap, purring like an angel on Ambien, and think, “Oh! It’s happening! We’ve bonded!”

Then the next day, you make eye contact and they knock a glass off the table while never breaking that gaze. It’s not passive-aggression. It’s art.

Cats Are Femme Fatales in Fur Pants

Cats are the noir film characters of the pet world. They’re beautiful, self-assured, emotionally layered, and you’re never entirely sure if they’re plotting to seduce you or frame you for murder. You fall in love knowing full well that you’ll never win.

And that’s the draw.

We don’t want safe. We want complicated.
We want a furred being with trust issues.
We want to say, “He doesn’t like strangers,” like it’s a brag.

Cat People: The Emotional Submissives of the Pet World

Let’s admit it: there is something deeply masochistic about cat people. We live to please a creature that routinely:

  • Rejects expensive beds in favor of your laptop

  • Screams at 4 a.m. because you didn’t refill the food bowl they didn’t finish

  • Attacks your ankle for existing in a hallway too confidently

And still, we’ll call in sick to cuddle them.
We’ll move apartments based on window quality.
We’ll learn the difference between a slow blink and a death threat.

We do this not because they love us. But because, once every 23 days, they might.

The Final Meow

Loving a cat is like dating someone who responds to your heartfelt texts with “k.”

And we love them more for it.

Because maybe, just maybe, one day… they’ll blink at us a little slower. Curl a little closer. Show us the tiniest crack in their armor—and we will feel chosen. Not needed. Never depended on. But chosen, for a moment, by the most unbothered creature in the house.

And then they’ll knock over your glass again.

And you’ll thank them for it.