Why Does Cat Poop Smell? The Surprising Truth About Diet and Digestion

I’m about to say something that might sound a little crazy to anyone who's ever scooped a litter box: Cat poop doesn’t have to smell.

I know, I know. That seems impossible, especially if you’ve been living with the eye-watering, gag-inducing reality of commercial cat food poop. But here’s the thing—when cats eat a raw, species-appropriate diet, their poop can be virtually odorless.

So, why does commercial cat food produce those nuclear-grade stink bombs, while raw-fed cats leave behind little scentless nuggets? The answer lies in digestion, ingredient quality, and gut bacteria.

Here’s why getting a second cat can transform your first cat’s life

The Science of Stinky Poop: What’s Really Happening in Your Cat’s Gut

Cats are obligate carnivores, which means their bodies are designed to digest meat, bones, and organs—not grains, plant fibers, or carbohydrates. When they eat food that aligns with their natural biology, their digestive system runs like a well-oiled machine.

But commercial pet food? That’s like throwing sugar into a gas tank. It disrupts everything.

1. Fillers, Carbs, and Indigestible Junk = Fermentation Factory

Most commercial cat foods—especially kibble—are packed with carbohydrates, plant proteins, and fillers like:

• Corn, wheat, rice, soy

• Pea protein, lentils, chickpeas

• Meat by-products and rendered ingredients

Here’s the problem: Cats lack the digestive enzymes to efficiently break down plant matter. So instead of being properly digested, these ingredients travel through the intestines, where they become a breeding ground for bacteria.

Bacteria that feed on undigested carbs produce sulfur compounds, ammonia, and other volatile gases—aka the reason why your cat’s litter box smells like a toxic waste site.

2. Artificial Additives and Preservatives = Gut Imbalance

Commercial foods often contain synthetic preservatives, artificial flavors, and colorants, all of which can disrupt the delicate balance of bacteria in your cat’s gut. A disrupted gut microbiome means:

• More bad bacteria

• More fermentation

• More pungent, room-clearing stools

3. Low-Quality Proteins = Rotting Waste

Even if a commercial food claims to be "high-protein," that protein might come from rendered meats, by-products, or plant sources. Poor-quality protein is harder to digest, which means more of it ends up fermenting in the intestines—leading to foul-smelling poop.

The Raw Diet Difference: Why Poop Becomes Odorless

When you switch a cat to a raw, meat-based diet, everything changes.

1. Highly Digestible, Species-Appropriate Nutrition

Raw food consists of muscle meat, organs, and bones—all things a cat’s digestive system is built to handle. There are:

• No fillers to ferment

• No starches to create gas

• No artificial additives to disrupt gut bacteria

That means the food gets fully digested and absorbed, leaving very little waste behind. The result? Small, firm, low-odor stools.

2. A Healthier Gut Microbiome

Cats on raw food develop a gut environment that supports beneficial bacteria instead of gas-producing, odor-causing microbes. With fewer carbs and processed ingredients feeding the bad bacteria, the digestive system stays balanced and efficient—no stink bombs necessary.

3. Less Waste, Less Poop, Less Smell

Another major perk of raw feeding? Your cat will poop less.

Because their body is actually using and absorbing the nutrients in their food, there's less waste to eliminate. Compare that to kibble, which contains so much indigestible filler that it practically guarantees frequent, oversized, smelly poops.

What to Expect When Switching to Raw

If you’re transitioning your cat from kibble or canned food to raw, you might notice:

• Smaller, firmer stools

• Less frequent pooping (raw-fed cats may poop just once every 1-2 days!)

• Poop that barely smells—or has no smell at all

It’s one of the first signs that your cat’s digestive system is working exactly as nature intended.

Final Thoughts: Poop Tells the Truth About Diet

If you ever need proof that raw feeding is better for cats, just follow your nose.

Commercial food? Nauseating, gag-worthy stink bombs.
Raw food? Minimal smell, minimal waste, minimal scooping hassle.

When cats eat the right food, their digestion improves, their gut bacteria thrive, and their poop becomes a non-event. So if you’re tired of holding your breath every time you clean the litter box, raw feeding might just be the best decision you ever make.

Because let’s be honest—life is better when your cat’s poop doesn’t smell like death itself.

Back to Blog List to Read More